Dutch Lib Dems open fire on Big Tech
The Dutch Liberal-Democrats (D66) launched a plan to restrain (mainly US) tech companies. In a 17-page document published earlier this month, the Lib Dems propose to cap market power by companies such as Facebook, Amazon, Apple, Netflix and Google (dubbed ‘FAANGS’) by adjusting current competition laws. The Parliament will discuss the plan with the Cabinet at the end of March, but not before the parliamentary fractions have had the chance to provide input on the Lib Dem initiative.
Decreasing support for digital platforms
The most striking fact is that D66 has always embraced tech firms as many of their voters find their way in the new digital economy. When even the Lib Dems are decreasing their support for the digital platforms, big tech could expect an increase of political pressure in the upcoming EP elections and probably in other elections as well.
The initiative by Mr. Kees Verhoeven MP consists of 14 measures to constrain the ‘Techgiants’. Notably, all the measures refer to revising current Dutch and European competition laws which, dating back to as early as the 1890 U.S. Sherman Antitrust Act. The 5 most eye-catching proposals are highlighted below:
1) Enable ex ante obligations in tech M&A’s
To prevent incorrect market definitions, competition regulation needs to adapt to the fact that platforms operate in multilateral markets;
2) Include privacy legislation in the scope of competition rules
D66 wants to oblige data-sharing to prevent tech platforms from gaining an unfair competitive advantage or raising the bar for market entrants;
3) The European Commission should investigate future market potentials when assessing acquisitions
This should prevent a continuous acquisition of start-ups by tech-platforms;
4) Introducing a new limit regarding the marketshare definition in the competition law
Article 102 VWEU should be adapted. D66 suggests the market shares of major tech companies should be below 50%;
5) Lowering turnover threshold for acquisitions
Based on the example of the Facebook takeover of Whatsapp. Following Germany and Austria, the initiator suggests to oblige companies to notify when a ‘target’ has substantial activities in NL;
For those who read carefully it is clear that the foundation for these issues was outlined in the earlier published D66/ALDE election program for the EP elections. The issue was discussed extensively between world and business leaders during last January’s World Economic Forum in Davos as well, where Big Tech was even compared to the Tobacco Industry. These developments could probably make it one of the main issues during the campaigns of the European Parliament elections in May.
Protectionism in the Netherlands
The initiative can be seen as part of a larger trend of protectionism in the Netherlands similar to the introduction of a ‘cool-down period’ for (hostile) takeover bids on Dutch companies. As the initiative is now primarily targeted at the US-tech companies, it would be even better if the plan would be linked to an ambition to stimulate Dutch (tech) companies to build up similar positions. When one decides to adjust competition law, it can never be adjusted based on developments in the tech-sector solely however. Therefore – and as the Cabinet has to formally react to the D66 plan – we assume that the competition directorate of the ministry of Economic Affairs will investigate the effects in a variety of business sectors.
As the Dutch government faces an unstable 2019 and Dutch competition law has not changed for a while, many of the measures proposed in the paper are expected to be input for the next Dutch coalition agreement or at least the next D66 election program. During a debate on competition in Dutch Parliament last week, a first introduction of Mr. Verhoeven’s plans was supported by both opposition and coalition. Parliament now has a month to comment on the Lib Dem initiative. After 21 March 21 the ministry of Economic Affairs will provide its view.
The initiative by Kees Verhoeven MP consists of 14 measures to constrain the ‘Techgiants’
Interested in our service? Contact us.
De @BoerBurgerB is in alle provincies de grootste partij geworden bij de Provinciale Statenverkiezingen. Uit de laatste berichten blijkt dat de partij ook in Utrecht de meeste zetels heeft behaald https://t.co/f1d6SEwCJU #ProvincialeVerkiezingen
Tijdens het #Campagneleidersdebat van @Machiavelli_NL in @Nieuwspoort, blikten vijf campagneleiders terug op hun campagnes en bespraken ze de verkiezingsresultaten: https://t.co/ER2AhhxaNj #verkiezingen #ProvincialeStaten #Waterschappen https://t.co/bVuWQZHKUR
Het #Campagneleidersdebat in @Nieuwspoort met @hannekevdwerf @ThierryAartsen, @LauraVissenberg, @DerkBoswijk, @emsent en @fonslambie #verkiezingen15maart @Machiavelli_NL https://t.co/ASE2PmdtAB
UPDATE DUTCH POLITICS: farmers’ party @BoerBurgerB emerged as the big winner of the Provincial Elections. As a result, BBB and left-wing alliance of @PvdA and @GroenLinks on course to become biggest parties in the Senate https://t.co/PIMJ9subHL #Dutchpolitics #elections2023
Kijk straks om 09:30 live mee naar het #Campagneleidersdebat Provinciale Statenverkiezingen 👇 https://t.co/UyLkdPwIl6 @Machiavelli_NL #verkiezingen15maart
Vandaag kan tot 21:00 gestemd worden voor de Provinciale Staten en de waterschappen! Weet jij al waar je dit gaat doen? Check https://t.co/AvNBMhJP30 #verkiezingen #ProvincialeStaten #waterschappen
Public Matters heeft weer een aantal nieuwe collega’s mogen verwelkomen! Daan de Haas en Wimer Heemskerk zijn recent begonnen als Account Executive en Emma Kempen, Jesse van der Genugten en Lotte van den Berg als Trainee https://t.co/wiS39qcN94 #werkenbijpm #yourvoiceheard https://t.co/RJdRbsnjDe
Traditiegetrouw blikken #campagneleiders de ochtend na de #verkiezingsavond bij @Machiavelli_NL terug op de gevoerde campagnes. Zijn de resultaten van de campagne zoals verwacht en wat zijn de lessen? Meld je aan via 👇 https://t.co/N24HLwg5PE
Linkse partijen dreigen tegen de klimaatplannen te stemmen als deze niet nog ambitieuzer worden. Ze gaan ervan uit dat het kabinet de steun van de linkse partijen nodig heeft in de Senaat na de verkiezingen op 15 maart https://t.co/rP9ITIcTlQ #klimaatplannen #verkiezingen2023
Public Matters feliciteert Johan Remkes met het winnen van de #Machiavelliprijs 2022. Remkes’ “scherpe blik op de inhoud en warm gevoel voor het sentiment” werd geprezen door de jury. Sinds 2010 is Public Matters trotse hoofdsponsor van @Machiavelli_NL https://t.co/rXAAdiJYIi